> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.theredlighthouse.org/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# A Maine School Board Denied a Church a Yearlong Lease. A Judge Found Bias and Awarded One Dollar.
- URL: https://www.theredlighthouse.org/advocate-hermon-pines-church-lease-one-dollar-ruling/
- Published: 2026-11-14T13:58:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-14T13:57:59.000Z
- Description: A federal judge ruled Friday that the Hermon School Committee in Maine showed bias against the Pines Church when it refused the congregation a yearlong lease at the high school. He left the vote standing and awarded one dollar plus fees. The Advocate on why the reasons matter more than the dollar.
- Author: The Red Lighthouse
- Tags: The Advocate, News Stories

Strip the case to its principle and it is not complicated. A public school that rents its rooms to the community may not refuse a church on better terms because it is a church.

On Friday, Chief United States District Judge Lance Walker of the District of Maine ruled that the Hermon School Committee did exactly that to the Pines Church, an evangelical congregation near Bangor, and its pastor, Matt Gioia.

He awarded them one dollar.

He did not overturn the committee's vote. And the reasons he gave matter more than the dollar.

## What the Church Asked For

Gioia moved his wife, Jess, and their six children from Colorado to Maine during the pandemic to plant the church, the Bangor Daily News reports. It grew quickly and was meeting in a movie theater in Orono, with room for about 150 people.

The church asked Hermon High School for a lease of a year: the auditorium and two classrooms on Sundays. In December 2022 the seven member school committee voted 4 to 1 to offer a month to month arrangement instead. A motion for a six month lease drew no second, according to a September 2025 order in the case.

The church sued in 2023 under the First Amendment and the Maine Human Rights Act. The case is *The Pines Church and Matt Gioia v. Hermon School Department*, No. 1:23-cv-00214.

## What the Judge Found

In a 37 page decision, the judge found that the church's religious affiliation was a "substantial factor" in the committee's decision, the Bangor Daily News reports, and that the proceedings carried "undertones and overtones" of hostility toward the church and its pastor.

He found that three members acted with what he called "bad motives." One, Christopher McLaughlin, the only member who voted against leasing to the church at all, asked what the judge called "intrusive" questions about the church's denomination and its views on diversity, equity and inclusion, abortion and sexuality. Another, Stephanie Oiler, raised cleaning, parking and snow removal. The judge wrote that her attitude toward the church was "anything but neutral." The third is a member named Shorey; the Bangor Daily News and the church's lawyers give her first name differently.

The church's lawyers, Advocates for Faith and Freedom, say the judge called the practical concerns "threadbare" and the month to month offer "an offer designed to be rejected." We have not read those lines in the decision ourselves, so we give them as the lawyers' account.

The superintendent, Micah Grant, had backed the year long lease. The judge called him a "guardrail" and faulted the committee for not following its own lawyers' advice.

## The Fair Point for Hermon

The committee had a real argument, and the judge granted part of it. No other group rented Hermon's school space by the year. A church asking for a standing Sunday lease was asking for something new.

Walker accepted that the arrangement was novel. He also declined to find that refusing the lease amounted to a policy of discrimination. His answer to the novelty point was short: being new is not a reason to treat a religious group worse.

That is the right line. A district can say no to a long lease for everyone. It cannot say no to the church because of what the church believes about marriage or abortion, and then reach for the snow plow as the reason.

## Why One Dollar

One dollar is what courts call nominal damages. It is how a judge records that a right was violated when the loss is hard to price. The church also gets its reasonable attorney's fees and costs, which in a case that ran three years will not be one dollar.

Neither the Bangor Daily News nor FOX 22 reported a response from the committee or whether it will appeal.

## The Liberty Runs Both Ways

The questions that sank Hermon were questions about belief. The same rule that protects an evangelical church in Hermon protects a mosque asking for a gym in Texas and a secular humanist group asking for a library room in Alabama. If a board may grade a renter's theology, it may grade anyone's.

The First Amendment does not ask whether a school board likes a church's views on sexuality. It asks whether the board treated the church like everyone else.

If your congregation rents public space, read your district's facilities policy this week. Know what it says before anyone has to ask.

## Sources

- Bangor Daily News, "Judge rules that Hermon School Committee discriminated against church," November 13, 2026: [bangordailynews.com](https://www.bangordailynews.com/2026/11/13/bangor/bangor-police-courts/hermon-maine-school-committee-pines-church-discrimination-decision/?ref=theredlighthouse.org)
- FOX 22 and ABC 7 Bangor (Susan Farley), "Judge rules that Hermon school committee discriminated against a church," November 13, 2026: [foxbangor.com](https://www.foxbangor.com/news/local/judge-rules-that-hermon-school-committee-discriminated-against-a-church/article%5F383848e7-c9c0-4e42-bb8b-1437d886b21d.html?ref=theredlighthouse.org)
- Advocates for Faith and Freedom, press release via Standard Newswire, November 13, 2026 (counsel for the church): [standardnewswire.com](https://standardnewswire.com/advocates-for-faith-freedom-wins-critical-religious-liberty-trial-federal-court-rules-maine-school-department-violated-churchs-first-amendment-rights/?ref=theredlighthouse.org)
- Order on motions in limine, The Pines Church and Matt Gioia v. Hermon School Department, No. 1:23-cv-00214-LEW (D. Me. Sept. 24, 2025): [courtlistener.com](https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/10677127/pines-church-v-hermon-school-department/?ref=theredlighthouse.org)