> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.theredlighthouse.org/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Indiana's Ten Commandments Monument Has Waited Outside a Bedford Church Since 2000. The Governor Wants It Back.
- URL: https://www.theredlighthouse.org/advocate-indiana-statehouse-ten-commandments-monument-dismiss/
- Published: 2026-10-25T12:58:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-25T12:58:00.000Z
- Description: On October 19 Governor Mike Braun asked a federal court to end the ACLU's challenge to a limestone Ten Commandments monument for the Indiana Statehouse lawn. The old Lemon test is gone. The fight now is over what history means.
- Author: The Red Lighthouse
- Tags: The Advocate, News Stories

Strip the Indiana fight to its principle and it is a question about a test that no longer exists.

A seven foot limestone monument carrying the Ten Commandments, the Bill of Rights and the Preamble to Indiana's 1851 Constitution has been waiting since 2000 to go up on the Statehouse lawn. A federal court blocked it then, applying the Supreme Court's old Lemon test. For more than twenty five years it has stood in front of a church in Bedford instead.

On Monday, October 19, Governor Mike Braun asked a federal court to dismiss the lawsuit that is now the last thing standing between that stone and the Statehouse. Whether he wins depends on what replaced Lemon, and nobody in this case agrees on that.

## How we got here

An earlier Ten Commandments monument stood on the Statehouse lawn from 1958 until a vandal toppled it in 1991, according to WBIW and The Indiana Citizen. In 2000, Governor Frank O'Bannon, a Democrat, accepted a limestone replacement donated by the Indiana Limestone Institute. The Indiana Civil Liberties Union, now the ACLU of Indiana, sued before it could be installed.

The district court applied the three part test from Lemon v. Kurtzman (1971). It found the monument's purpose religious and said a reasonable observer would see government endorsement of religion, The Indiana Citizen reported. A permanent injunction followed in 2002, and the Seventh Circuit affirmed it.

Then the ground moved. In Kennedy v. Bremerton School District (2022), the Supreme Court said the Establishment Clause is to be read by reference to historical practices and understandings, and set Lemon aside. Indiana asked to reopen its old case under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b)(5), which allows a court to lift an order when there has been "a significant change in the law."

On May 28, 2026, U.S. District Judge Sara Evans Barker of the Southern District of Indiana lifted the injunction, Bloomberg Law reported. She rejected the argument that the state had waited too long, reasoning that the justices did not make plain that Lemon was gone until 2022 and that Braun did not take office until 2025\. But she did not hold that the monument is constitutional. The record, she said, did not let her reach that question.

So the fight began again. The ACLU of Indiana pressed its challenge, and on Monday the state, represented by Attorney General Todd Rokita's office and the religious liberty firm Becket, asked the court to end it.

## The two arguments

The state's case, as WPTA 21Alive and WBIW reported it, is that Kennedy buried Lemon and that Van Orden v. Perry (2005), which upheld a Ten Commandments monument on the grounds of the Texas State Capitol, controls. Joseph Davis, senior counsel at Becket, told WPTA: "Lemon may be dead, but its ghost still haunts America's public square." He also said, "The ACLU is just trying to finish in the courts what the vandal started at the statehouse."

The ACLU's case deserves a fair hearing, because it is not a Lemon argument wearing a disguise. Earlier in this litigation it told the court, as The Indiana Citizen reported, that the Supreme Court still reads the Establishment Clause through history and tradition, and that history cuts against Indiana here. The cross upheld in American Legion v. American Humanist Association had stood for nearly a century. "There is no longstanding tradition of the practice of displaying the complete text of the Ten Commandments," the ACLU wrote.

That is a serious point. The history and tradition test is not a blank check. It asks a question, and the answer depends on the facts of the monument, the place and the practice.

## The turn

Here is what makes Indiana unusual. The state is not asking to put up something new. It is asking to put back something the state had for thirty three years, from 1958 to 1991, until a vandal took it down. That is the history the state will lean on, and it is a more concrete history than most Ten Commandments cases can point to.

The ACLU will answer that a monument's age on the lawn is not the same as a national tradition of displaying sacred text on public ground. The court will have to decide whose history counts.

And here is the line that should hold whichever side a reader is on. A history and tradition test protects a monument because the people kept it, not because the state likes what it says. If that reasoning keeps the Ten Commandments on the Indiana Statehouse lawn, it will be asked to protect other old monuments whose message some readers will not share. The liberty we claim for our own heritage has to shield the heritage of our neighbors, or it is only a preference with a gavel.

## What to watch

The motion is now before the Southern District of Indiana. None of the reports we read gave a date for a ruling. Whatever it decides, the losing side can appeal to the Seventh Circuit, the same court that affirmed the ban in the first place.

If you live in Indiana, read the filings rather than the headlines. The case is Indiana Civil Liberties Union v. Braun, No. 1:00-cv-00811, and both sides' arguments are a better civics lesson than most of what will be said about them.

If this was useful, pass it to someone who will be arguing about it at dinner. That is what the free edition is for.

## Sources

- WPTA 21Alive, "Braun asks federal court to dismiss lawsuit challenging Statehouse Ten Commandments monument," October 21, 2026: [21alivenews.com](https://www.21alivenews.com/2026/10/21/braun-aks-federal-court-dismiss-lawsuit-challenging-statehouse-ten-commandments-monument/?ref=theredlighthouse.org)
- WBIW, "Governor Braun asks Federal Court to dismiss ACLU lawsuit over Statehouse Ten Commandments Monument," October 22, 2026: [wbiw.com](https://www.wbiw.com/2026/10/22/governor-braun-asks-federal-court-to-dismiss-aclu-lawsuit-over-statehouse-ten-commandments-monument/?ref=theredlighthouse.org)
- Bloomberg Law, "Indiana Gets New Chance to Erect Ten Commandments Monument," May 29, 2026: [news.bgov.com](https://news.bgov.com/health-law-and-business/indiana-gets-new-chance-to-erect-ten-commandments-monument?ref=theredlighthouse.org)
- The Indiana Citizen, "Law has not changed: ACLU of Indiana argues putting Ten Commandments statue on Statehouse lawn is still unconstitutional," January 29, 2026: [indianacitizen.org](https://indianacitizen.org/law-has-not-changed-aclu-of-indiana-argues-putting-ten-commandments-statue-on-statehouse-lawn-is-still-unconstitutional/?ref=theredlighthouse.org)
- InkFreeNews, "Braun Seeks Dismissal Of Lawsuit Over Proposed Statehouse Ten Commandments Monument," October 21, 2026: [inkfreenews.com](https://www.inkfreenews.com/2026/10/21/braun-seeks-dismissal-of-lawsuit-over-proposed-statehouse-ten-commandments-monument/?ref=theredlighthouse.org)