> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.theredlighthouse.org/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Colorado Pays for Free Preschool at Two Thousand Schools. The Justices Asked Why Not Thirty Four Catholic Ones.
- URL: https://www.theredlighthouse.org/advocate-st-mary-v-roy-colorado-catholic-preschools-argument/
- Published: 2026-11-04T13:58:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-04T13:58:00.000Z
- Description: On Election Day the Supreme Court heard St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy, over Colorado's refusal to admit Catholic preschools to its free program without a nondiscrimination pledge. The question is whether a rule that bends for other reasons is general enough to bind them.
- Author: The Red Lighthouse
- Tags: The Advocate, News Stories

Strip the case to its principle and it is a question about one word: general.

Since 1990 the rule has been that a law which is neutral toward religion and applies to everyone generally can bind a believer even when it burdens his faith. A law that singles out religion, or carves out exceptions for some reasons but not for religious ones, has to clear the highest bar the Constitution sets.

On Tuesday, November 3, the Supreme Court heard a case about which kind of rule Colorado wrote for its free preschool program. Thirty four Catholic preschools run by the Archdiocese of Denver are on the outside of it, according to CBS News. About two thousand other preschools are in.

Five justices sounded ready to say the state has to explain why.

## The Program and the Promise

Colorado's voters approved universal preschool in 2020\. The program now pays for fifteen hours a week, worth more than six thousand dollars a year to a family, according to CBS News. Roughly two thousand providers take part, public and private, secular and religious.

To join, a preschool signs a nondiscrimination agreement. It promises every child an equal opportunity to enroll regardless of race, religion, sexual orientation, gender identity and other listed traits. Colorado reads that to require a participating school to admit LGBTQ children and children of LGBTQ parents, as SCOTUSblog reports.

The archdiocese's preschools enroll families who accept Catholic teaching on marriage, family and sexual identity. They asked for an exemption. Colorado said no. The archdiocese, two parishes (one of whose preschools has since closed) and two parents sued, arguing that shutting religious schools out of the program violates the Free Exercise Clause. The federal district court and the Tenth Circuit both sided with the state, holding that the requirement is neutral and applies to everyone.

## What the Justices Asked

Nicholas Reaves of the Becket Fund argued for the schools. He said they "exist to pass on the faith to the next generation." His argument was not that the rule is hostile on its face. It was that the rule is not general, because the program already bends its admissions for other reasons, including placement preferences and accommodations for children with disabilities and from low income families.

Helen Norton, Colorado's deputy solicitor general, answered that the state "welcomes" religious preschools, that they stay free to teach what they believe, and that they must meet the same conditions as everyone else taking public money. The preferences, she said, do not excuse anyone from the nondiscrimination rule. The federal government argued in support of the schools.

Justice Kavanaugh pressed the arithmetic. With more than two thousand preschools in the program and thirty four Catholic ones asking out, he asked, "Why not seek the win-win?" Justice Barrett asked why a state may impose a condition it knows certain schools cannot accept. Justice Gorsuch asked what would be left of the Court's older free exercise cases "if everything turned on express discrimination." Chief Justice Roberts said the effect of Colorado's rule was "pretty much the same" as the Maine law the Court struck down in 2022.

The other side of the bench pressed just as hard. Justice Kagan said the Maine line of cases rested on "a nondiscrimination principle," and asked whether the schools now want something more than equal treatment. Justice Jackson told Reaves, "your schools want to discriminate by exclusion." Justice Sotomayor asked whether a religious preschool could turn a child away merely because the parents are gay, and whether the same logic would let a school turn away Black children.

## The Fair Point

Concede what Colorado gets right. The state did not write a law aimed at Catholics. Norton noted that the requirement existed before religious schools were brought in, and no one has shown a motive to target them. A family with two mothers who wants a free preschool seat near home is not an abstraction. Sotomayor put it bluntly near the end: whichever line of cases the Court follows, there will be "a great cost to someone."

But the question in front of the Court is not whether the state's goal is decent. It is whether a rule that already makes room for some reasons may refuse to make room for faith. The liberty that lets a parish run its preschool by its own teaching is the same liberty that protects the congregation down the street whose teaching the parish rejects. A rule that bends for every reason but religion is not general. It is a choice.

## What Comes Next

SCOTUSblog reports the Court seemed poised to rule for the schools and to apply a stricter test than the lower courts used, either deciding the case itself or sending it back. A decision is expected next year.

Until then, read the argument for yourself before anyone tells you what it meant. If this helped, pass it to someone who runs a church preschool or sits on a school board.

## Sources

- SCOTUSblog, Amy Howe, "Court seems poised to side with Catholic preschools in religious discrimination dispute," November 3, 2026: [https://www.scotusblog.com/2026/11/court-seems-poised-to-side-with-catholic-preschools-in-religious-discrimination-dispute/](https://www.scotusblog.com/2026/11/court-seems-poised-to-side-with-catholic-preschools-in-religious-discrimination-dispute/?ref=theredlighthouse.org)
- CBS News, Melissa Quinn, "Supreme Court seems likely to side with Catholic preschools in fight over Colorado program," November 3, 2026: [https://www.cbsnews.com/news/supreme-court-st-mary-catholic-parish-v-roy-colorado-preschool/](https://www.cbsnews.com/news/supreme-court-st-mary-catholic-parish-v-roy-colorado-preschool/?ref=theredlighthouse.org)
- St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy, No. 25-581, Legal Information Institute case page: [https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/cert/25-581](https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/cert/25-581?ref=theredlighthouse.org)