> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.theredlighthouse.org/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Wisconsin Votes November 3 on Keeping Churches Open in Any Emergency. The State's Catholic Conference Took No Side.
- URL: https://www.theredlighthouse.org/advocate-wisconsin-places-of-worship-amendment-november-3/
- Published: 2026-10-19T12:58:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-19T12:58:00.000Z
- Description: On November 3 Wisconsin voters decide whether to write a flat ban on emergency closures of places of worship into the state constitution. The Bishop of Madison supports it, the state Catholic conference stayed neutral, and the fair objection deserves a hearing.
- Author: The Red Lighthouse
- Tags: The Advocate, News Stories

Strip the ballot question to its principle and it is one sentence long: in Wisconsin, an emergency would no longer be a lawful reason for government to close a house of worship.

Voters decide on November 3\. If they say yes, that sentence goes into Article I, Section 18 of the state constitution, the section that already deals with religious liberty.

The Bishop of Madison is for it. The Wisconsin Catholic Conference says it did not take a position.

That gap is the most interesting thing about the measure, and it is not a scandal. It is a lawyer's question.

## What the amendment says

The measure is titled "Prohibit Government Closure of Places of Worship During Emergencies Amendment (2026)," as EWTN News reported on October 16\. It adds language to Section 18 providing that neither "the state or a political subdivision of the state" may "order the closure of or forbid gatherings in places of worship" during a state of emergency, including a public health emergency. The Wisconsin Examiner's ballot guide describes it the same way: a yes vote bars local, county and state governments from closing places of worship in an emergency; a no vote leaves the constitution as it is.

Two definitions matter. "Political subdivision" reaches counties and cities, not only Madison. And "places of worship" is not limited to churches. The text protects a mosque, a synagogue and a temple exactly as it protects a parish.

## Where it came from

Republican lawmakers wrote it in response to COVID public health orders. In 2020, Dane County capped indoor worship, including Mass, at fifty people, according to both EWTN News and the Wisconsin Examiner. EWTN reports that the Diocese of Madison threatened to sue; the Examiner describes the threat as coming from a coalition of Catholic affiliated law firms. Either way, the county changed its rules.

When the measure had its first hearing in 2023, its lead Assembly author, Rep. Ty Bodden, told the Examiner, "This amendment will protect our constitutional rights," and said nine other states had passed similar measures since 2021\. Its lead Senate author, Sen. Cory Tomczyk, said it "makes crystal clear that these places of worship shall not be forced to close."

## The federal floor already moved

On November 25, 2020, the US Supreme Court granted the Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn an injunction against New York's executive order capping attendance at religious services at ten and twenty five people. The Court's docket shows concurrences from Justices Gorsuch and Kavanaugh and dissents from Chief Justice Roberts and Justices Breyer, Sotomayor and Kagan.

So a church in Wisconsin facing a capacity order already has federal precedent to point to. What the amendment would add is something different: not a case by case argument in court, but a flat bar written into the state constitution.

## The fair objection

Here the other side deserves its best case, and in 2023 it made one. Peter Bakken, speaking for the Wisconsin Council of Churches, took no side but told legislators that existing state and federal guarantees could already be used to challenge harmful orders, and that the amendment's key terms could spark definitional disputes. Sen. Bob Wirch, a Democrat, said the pandemic closures were not arbitrary, pointing to the death toll at the time.

Those are serious points. A flat bar admits no exception, and emergencies are, by definition, the situations nobody planned for.

## And the answer to it

Bishop Donald Hying of Madison wrote in an October 15 column in the Madison Catholic Herald that a ballot initiative "speaks to that right" to religious liberty, EWTN reported. David Earleywine, executive director of the Wisconsin Catholic Conference, told EWTN the conference "did not take a position on the constitutional amendment" but had discussed possible changes with its authors. He did not say which.

A bishop for it and a conference that helped shape it but stayed neutral is not a contradiction. It is what careful people do with a constitutional amendment: want the principle, and worry about the wording.

The liberty to gather that a Catholic parish claims in Madison must shield the mosque in Milwaukee on the same terms, or it shields no one. On that point, at least, the text gets it right.

## What you can do

If you vote in Wisconsin, read the full question before November 3; it is printed in the Examiner's guide linked below. Ask your pastor whether your congregation has a view. Then vote your conscience on the wording, not only the principle.

If you do not vote in Wisconsin, ask whether your state has done the same thing. In 2023, Bodden counted nine that had.

The Red Lighthouse covers religious liberty from the court record, not the outrage cycle. If that is the kind of reporting you want more of, consider joining as a member.

## Sources

- EWTN News, "Wisconsin voters to weigh ban on church closures in health emergencies," October 16, 2026: [ewtnnews.com](https://ewtnnews.com/world/us/wisconsin-voters-to-weigh-ban-on-church-closures-in-health-emergencies?ref=theredlighthouse.org)
- Wisconsin Examiner, "Places of Worship Amendment" (2026 general election guide): [wisconsinexaminer.com](https://wisconsinexaminer.com/?p=48080&ref=theredlighthouse.org)
- Wisconsin Examiner, "Proposed constitutional amendment would exempt worship venues from emergency closings," July 19, 2023: [wisconsinexaminer.com](https://wisconsinexaminer.com/2023/07/19/proposed-constitutional-amendment-would-exempt-worship-venues-from-emergency-closings/?ref=theredlighthouse.org)
- Supreme Court of the United States, docket 20A87, Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn v. Cuomo: [supremecourt.gov](https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/20a87.html?ref=theredlighthouse.org)
- SCOTUSblog case file, Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn v. Cuomo: [scotusblog.com](https://www.scotusblog.com/cases/roman-catholic-diocese-of-brooklyn-new-york-v-cuomo/?ref=theredlighthouse.org)