A Catholic Charity Lost Two Women's Addiction Designations. A Federal Judge Said Michigan Could Do That.
Michigan pulled two women's addiction designations from a Catholic counseling center over a pledge against abortion and contraception referrals. A federal judge found no religious hostility, yet agreed with the charity on one point.
Begin with what the ruling did not say, because that is where the anger will gather.
On Thursday, November 12, Chief Judge Hala Y. Jarbou of the federal court in western Michigan threw out a lawsuit brought by Catholic Charities of Ingham, Eaton and Clinton Counties. The charity had lost two state designations for its women's addiction counseling in Lansing after its staff signed a pledge not to refer clients for abortion or contraception.
The judge did not find that Michigan was right about Catholic teaching. She did not find the charity's beliefs unwelcome. On one point she agreed with the charity outright.
She still dismissed every claim it brought. The reason is worth understanding before anyone shares a headline about it.
The Program
The charity runs its substance use counseling under the name Cristo Rey Counseling Center. Part of that work was paid through a federal block grant for substance use prevention and treatment, which reaches local providers through a regional plan called Mid-State Health Network.
Cristo Rey held two designations under that system, Women's Specialty Services and Enhanced Women's Services. According to the opinion, the charity adopted a "Core Values and Commitment to Mission" pledge that its staff had to sign by about November 30, 2025. The pledge bars staff from referring clients to resources for abortion or contraception. The charity offers natural family planning and abstinence support instead.
Mid-State learned of the pledge in December 2025, raised it with the state health department in January, and met with Cristo Rey staff in March. On May 22, 2026, the state's substance use division discontinued both women's designations, citing a failure to provide required services. The state later let the charity keep serving those clients with its own money, so long as it did not advertise them as the designated programs.
Alliance Defending Freedom sued on the charity's behalf in June. "No organization should have to choose between its faith and serving the public good," ADF attorney Ryan Tucker told WILX at the time.
What the Court Held
The heart of the opinion is a single legal step. When a rule is neutral toward religion and applies to everyone alike, a court reviews it under the most forgiving test the law has, rational basis. Judge Jarbou found the service requirements were that kind of rule. She found they applied to religious and secular providers alike.
The charity's lawyers pointed to an earlier Michigan case, Buck v. Gordon, where a Catholic foster care agency had pointed to evidence that state officials were hostile to its faith. The judge answered in one line: "There is no comparable evidence of religious hostility here."
She rejected the rest in turn. The charity had no property right in a designation its contract never guaranteed. Losing funding for declining a service is a condition of a program, she held, not compelled speech. The dispute concerned services to outside clients, not the charity's internal religious life, so church autonomy did not apply. And the facts the charity itself alleged, she found, showed it lost the designations for not meeting service requirements, not as retaliation. She denied the preliminary injunction and granted the motions to dismiss.
The Point the Charity Won
Here is the part that will not make the headlines. After the dispute began, Mid-State adopted a new procedure requiring religious providers to disclose the limits their beliefs place on their services. The judge agreed with the charity on its reach: "CCIEC is correct that Mid-State's procedure goes farther than what the law requires in terms of its disclosure requirements."
It did not save the case. The disclosure rule, she found, was not what cost the charity its designations. But it is on the record, and a rule that asks more of religious providers than the law requires is a rule someone will challenge again.
Why It Cuts Both Ways
Concede the fair point first. A state that pays for a women's treatment program may define what that program must offer. If it could not, every provider with a conviction could rewrite every public program, and not all of those convictions would be ones you share.
But the same principle that lets Michigan set neutral conditions forbids it from setting them because of who is asking. That is why the judge measured this record against Buck before she ruled. The protection is still there. This time, on this record, she did not find the hostility it guards against.
The liberty a Catholic charity claims must also protect the provider whose convictions it opposes, or it protects no one.
No appeal had been reported in the sources we read when we filed.
If this helped you think it through, share it with someone who serves on the board of a ministry that takes public money. That is who this ruling was written for.
Sources
- Opinion and order, Catholic Charities of Ingham, Eaton & Clinton Counties v. Hertel, No. 1:26-cv-1941 (W.D. Mich. Nov. 12, 2026): justia.com
- Religion Clause, "Court Upholds Cut-Off of Funding to Catholic Charities' Substance Abuse Counseling Center in Michigan," Nov. 16, 2026: religionclause.blogspot.com
- WILX, "Catholic Charities sues Michigan over loss of women's services designation," June 29, 2026: wilx.com
Comments ()