A Prayer Room Leased a Storefront in Downtown Dover. Now It Is Suing the City Over a Permit.
New Hampshire law bars towns from regulating buildings primarily used for religious purposes. Dover says a storefront prayer room still needs a conditional use permit. The case may turn on one word.
Strip the Dover case to its principle and it fits in one sentence. In New Hampshire, a town may not put a place of worship through a zoning review it would not put a shop through.
That sentence is not a slogan. It is close to the text of a state law, RSA 674:76, signed by then Governor Chris Sununu in 2022. The law says zoning ordinances and site plan rules may not prohibit, regulate or restrict land or structures "primarily used for religious purposes." Towns keep their objective rules on height, setbacks, lot size and the like, so long as those rules apply the same way to religious and nonreligious uses.
A small Christian group called The Prayer Room at Dover leased a ground floor storefront in downtown Dover this year, intending to hold worship and prayer gatherings there. The city told it to apply for a conditional use permit first. The group refused. This month it sued.
The whole case may turn on one word in the statute. It is not "religious."
What the city asked for, and why
According to the lawsuit, as reported by New Hampshire Public Radio and NH Journal, Dover's zoning staff asked the group in April about its hours, expected attendance and parking. Religious use is not listed among the approved uses in that downtown district's zoning table. So, the city says, the group needs a conditional use permit, the same as any use the table does not name.
Dover's lead attorney, Joshua Wyatt, made that case in an October 6 letter to the group's lawyers. The permit process, he wrote, "applies neutrally and equally to all religious and non-religious uses not already listed in this district's zoning table." He told the group that staff would help with the application and that he expected the Planning Board could approve it in a single meeting, though he could not promise that.
That is a fair point, and it deserves to be stated at full strength. Dover is not saying churches are unwelcome downtown. It is saying the table lists what it lists, anything off the list gets a hearing, and a prayer room is off the list like a dozen other things would be. If the rule truly falls on every unlisted use alike, it looks like the kind of neutral rule the 2022 law still allows.
Where the argument turns
Here is the turn. The 2022 law does not say "religious uses must be treated like other unlisted uses." It says towns may not regulate structures primarily used for religious purposes, except through objective dimensional rules that apply equally to everyone. A conditional use review is not a setback or a height limit. It is a discretionary hearing on whether the use itself may go there.
The group's complaint, filed by the Christian advocacy organization Cornerstone, presses exactly that. It argues that a restaurant, a retail shop or an office could move into the same storefront without any conditional use permit, and that the prayer room is being sent to a hearing for no reason other than that it is a place of worship. It asks a court to order Dover to drop the permit requirement and to award nominal damages.
The city has an answer, and it rests on the word "primarily." According to NH Journal, Dover's position is that the storefront sits in a multi use building, and that the building's dominant use, not the tenant's, decides whether the statute applies. If a court agrees, a congregation in a rented storefront would have less protection under the 2022 law than a congregation that owns its own building.
Neither side's reading is frivolous. That is why the case is worth watching.
The principle underneath
A permit hearing sounds harmless, and Dover may be sincere that it would approve this one quickly. But the reason legislatures write laws like RSA 674:76 is that a hearing is where a neighbour's dislike of a congregation becomes a vote. The protection is not a promise that every hearing goes well. It is the absence of the hearing.
And the protection is not only for prayer rooms that look like this one. The same text shields a mosque in a strip mall, a synagogue above a shop and a storefront church whose theology you find strange. The liberty that lets a Christian prayer group open its doors on Central Avenue is the liberty that lets the next group, whoever it is, open theirs. If it does not cover them, it will not cover you either.
What we do not know yet
Neither report names the court where the case was filed, and we have not seen the docket. NH Journal reports that Wyatt declined to comment on the lawsuit itself. We will report the city's formal response when it files one.
What you can do
If your church rents rather than owns, find out today what your town's zoning table says about religious use in your district. Ask your pastor whether anyone has ever checked. Most congregations learn the answer only when a lease is already signed.
And pray for the people of The Prayer Room and for the officials of Dover, that the dispute is settled by the text of the law, in good faith, on both sides.
Sources
- New Hampshire Public Radio, "Dover sued over zoning fight involving storefront church," October 16, 2026: nhpr.org
- NH Journal, "Cornerstone Claims Dover Zoning Regs Violate Religious Freedom," October 19, 2026: nhjournal.com
- New Hampshire Revised Statutes, RSA 674:76, Religious Use of Land and Structures (2022, 291:1): gc.nh.gov
Comments ()