Oklahoma's Charter Board Won the Court Order It Asked For. Now It Has Voted to Appeal It.

Oklahoma's charter board voted 7 to 0 to appeal the federal order that paused its nonsectarian rule, an order its own lawyers called necessary. The attorney general says the board has no standing. Here is how a Jewish charter school left the board caught between two masters.

Oklahoma's Charter Board Won the Court Order It Asked For. Now It Has Voted to Appeal It.

Strip the case to its principle and it is still strange. On Friday, October 23, Oklahoma's Statewide Charter School Board voted 7 to 0 to appeal a federal court order. The board's own lawyers had told that court the order was necessary for board members to keep their oath of office.

The order is the one a federal judge in the Western District of Oklahoma issued on September 24. It blocks the state from enforcing the part of its charter school law that requires every charter school to be nonsectarian, at least against the proposed Ben Gamla Jewish Charter School, while the school's lawsuit goes forward. The board had filed a brief in April supporting the school's request for it.

So why would a board appeal a ruling it asked for and won?

How the board got here

Begin with the law. Oklahoma's Charter Schools Act says charter schools must be nonsectarian. In 2024 the Oklahoma Supreme Court used that rule, and the state and federal constitutions, to block St. Isidore of Seville, a Catholic virtual charter school. The U.S. Supreme Court split evenly on the appeal, which left the Oklahoma ruling standing without a national answer.

Ben Gamla, a proposed Jewish charter school founded by former Florida congressman Peter Deutsch, applied next. In February the board turned it down 8 to 0, citing the 2024 state ruling. The foundation sued. On September 24 the federal judge held that the nonsectarian rule "expressly discriminates against otherwise eligible recipients solely because of their religious character," a Free Exercise problem under Espinoza and Carson v. Makin, and paused it.

With the rule paused, the board voted again on October 12. The application got four votes. It needed five of nine seats, with one member absent and one seat vacant. It failed.

The attorney general's turn

Then the state's own lawyer stepped in. On Thursday, October 22, Attorney General Gentner Drummond issued a binding opinion saying state law sets a closed, two step application process, so a third vote on Ben Gamla would be illegal. His press secretary, Leslie Berger, called the board's next move "strange," said his office would not spend state money on an appeal the board has no standing to bring, and noted that a party generally cannot appeal an order it asked for and received.

Board Chair Brian Shellem's answer, as reported by Oklahoma Watch and News 9, is that the board is caught between two masters. He cited the supremacy clause in the Oklahoma Constitution to say the board must follow federal law, said the attorney general's opinion leaves the board unable to vote, and called the appeal its only remaining option. Board member Jared Buswell's motion directed lawyers to file "in order to preserve all of our options." Shellem said the deadline to file was Monday. We have not yet seen confirmation that the notice was filed.

The fair point on the other side

Concede what the critics get right. Americans United and allied groups, which intervened in the case, warned after the September ruling of a "dangerous sea change for our democracy." Oklahoma Rabbi Daniel Kaiman, an intervenor, called the school "nothing but a Trojan horse for creating religious public schools." KGOU reported that Deutsch, in an October 8 email, described a first year online high school of 10 students and a larger goal of Jewish religious charter schools across the country. That is a real question about what a charter school is, and the Supreme Court has not answered it.

But the principle cuts both ways, which is why it is worth holding. If a state may shut out an otherwise qualified applicant only because it is religious, it may shut out a Catholic school, a Jewish school, an evangelical school or a Muslim one on the same terms. The liberty a Christian parent claims in Oklahoma has to cover the Jewish founder in the same line, or it covers nobody.

What to watch

The board meets again on November 5. If the notice was filed, the Tenth Circuit will have to decide whether a board that supported an injunction can now challenge it. Either way, the question the Supreme Court left open in the St. Isidore case is walking back toward it, one awkward vote at a time.

If you want the cases like this one explained before the headlines arrive, The Advocate is free to share. Send it to the friend at your table who always asks what the court actually said.

Sources

  • Oklahoma Watch via KOSU, "Oklahoma charter board votes to appeal a court order it asked for and won," October 26, 2026: kosu.org
  • News 9, "Oklahoma charter school board votes to appeal Ben Gamla Jewish school ruling," October 23, 2026: news9.com
  • KGOU, "Ben Gamla Jewish Charter School narrowly rejected by Oklahoma Statewide Charter School Board," October 12, 2026: kgou.org
  • K-12 Dive, "Federal court clears way for first religious public charter school," September 25, 2026: k12dive.com