A Missouri Jail Offered to Let a Guard Hand Out Communion. The Archbishop Sued Instead.
The Archdiocese of St. Louis sued on October 5 over clergy access to immigration detainees at a Missouri county jail, where priests say they cannot hear confession or say Mass. DHS calls the claims false, and no court has ruled. Here is the principle at stake, and the fair point the jail makes.
Strip the case to its principle and it is not complicated: a person the government locks up does not lose the right to pray, and the government that holds him owes him a way to do it.
On Monday, October 5, the Archdiocese of St. Louis and Archbishop Mitchell Rozanski sued in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri. The defendants, according to Reuters, are top Homeland Security officials and the local sheriff. The place at issue is the Ste. Genevieve County jail, which the archdiocese says holds roughly 150 immigration detainees, most of them Hispanic Catholics.
Their complaint is specific. Clergy may visit only in a four hour window on Mondays, and only by telephone handset through a glass partition. Priests, the archbishop says, cannot hear confessions, celebrate Mass or anoint the sick. The jail's counter offer, per Reuters, was that a priest could place consecrated hosts in a container and a guard would pass them to the detainees.
Rozanski called that sacrilegious. Is he asking for a favor, or for a right?
Begin with the law, because that is where the answer lives. The suit, as reported by Religion News Service, rests on four grounds: the First Amendment's Free Exercise Clause, the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA), Missouri's Religious Freedom Restoration Act, and the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act. RLUIPA is the statute built for exactly this setting. It protects the religious exercise of people held in institutions. We are describing what the plaintiffs allege. No court has ruled on any of it.
Now concede the fair point. A jail has a real interest in contraband, and a sheriff's office is entitled to say so. St. Louis Public Radio quotes Maj. Jason Schott, chief deputy of the Ste. Genevieve County Sheriff's Office, saying the office had not yet received the lawsuit and would send it to legal counsel. Earlier, he said, priests may give a wrapped wafer for staff to pass to detainees, but may not contact detainees directly, to prevent contraband. That is a security reason, stated plainly, and a court will weigh it.
Here is where the argument turns, and it is the part worth repeating at dinner. The archdiocese does not claim special treatment. In the complaint's words, as quoted by St. Louis Public Radio, it "only requests the same access as these other groups." Reuters reports the relief sought is the level of access already granted to consular officials and attorneys. And the suit says ICE's own website allows clergy to visit at any time with notice to the sheriff's office, which means the dispute is partly about whether a federal agency follows its own published rule.
The reply from the government side comes through Religion News Service. DHS called the allegations "FALSE," said the facility is "a non-contact county jail, not an ICE facility," and said detainees "are given the opportunity to practice their religions," including access to priests and sacraments. Reuters and St. Louis Public Radio, reporting earlier, had no DHS comment, so treat the DHS statement as the department's current position and the facts as contested. Whether the jail is an ICE facility matters, because the plaintiffs also ask for relief requiring ICE to restore religious freedoms for priests and detainees nationwide.
The pluralist test is this. Suppose the plaintiff were an imam or a Baptist chaplain, and the facts were the same. A rule that gets the priest through the door gets the imam through too. A rule that fails the imam fails the priest. The liberty claimed here has to shield the person you disagree with, or it shields no one.
The case is not alone. RNS reports two similar suits in Illinois and Minnesota involving Catholic leaders, both of which won temporary rulings giving clergy varying levels of access. RNS says this is the first time a Catholic bishop has individually joined one of these immigration related religious suits, and counts 23 cases filed by religious groups against federal immigration policy since January 2025, at least 15 of them claiming religious rights violations.
What you can do. Read the complaint when it posts, not the headlines about it. Ask your own congregation whether anyone is visiting the detention facilities near you, and what the rules there are. And watch for the first hearing in Missouri: a judge's first look at the visitation policy will say more than any press release.
The Red Lighthouse follows the courts so you do not have to guess what they said. Members keep that reporting independent.
Sources
- Reuters, "Catholic diocese sues US government seeking clergy access to detainees," October 5, 2026 (via WMBD): https://wmbdradio.com/2026/10/05/catholic-diocese-sues-us-government-seeking-clergy-access-to-detainees/
- Religion News Service, "For the first time, a Catholic archbishop sues Trump over access to immigrant detainees," October 7, 2026: https://religionnews.com/2026/10/07/st-louis-archbishop-files-lawsuit-against-trump-administration/
- St. Louis Public Radio, October 6, 2026: https://www.stlpr.org/race-identity-and-faith/2026-10-06/st-louis-archdiocese-lawsuit-alleges-violation-ice-detainees-religious-rights
Comments ()