A Federal Judge Opened Tennessee's Charter Door to a Christian School. He Did Not Promise It a Charter.

On November 6 a federal judge ruled that Knox County cannot turn away a proposed Christian charter school because it is religious. The order covers one school and grants no charter. The Advocate on what the ruling held and whom else it protects.

A Federal Judge Opened Tennessee's Charter Door to a Christian School. He Did Not Promise It a Charter.

Start with what the ruling did not say. Much of the praise and the alarm has gone further than the text.

On Friday, November 6, United States District Judge Charles Atchley ruled for Wilberforce Academy of Knoxville, a proposed Christian charter school, in its lawsuit against the Knox County Board of Education. He held that Tennessee's requirement that charter schools be "nonsectarian" and "nonreligious" violates the First Amendment as applied to Wilberforce.

He did not grant the school a charter, strike the rule for the whole state, or order any public money spent.

The ruling is narrower than the headlines suggest. If it survives appeal, its reach could be wider than it first appears.

What the Judge Held

The case is The Wilberforce Academy of Knoxville v. Knox County Board of Education, No. 3:25-cv-00584, in the Eastern District of Tennessee. Wilberforce is a proposed tuition free, explicitly Christian school for kindergarten through eighth grade. It sued late in 2025. The Knoxville News Sentinel says the suit was filed in November, and WVLT says December. The school went to court after the board said its application would be rejected because Tennessee law requires an applicant to affirm that its school will not be religious.

The board's main defense concerned procedure. It argued that Wilberforce had never filed a full application and so had nothing to sue over. Chalkbeat reported that Judge Atchley rejected that argument in late May. Both sides then asked him to decide the case without a trial.

He did. The News Sentinel quotes his central holding: once a state opens a program to private participants, it "may not prohibit them from receiving a public benefit solely because of their intended religious use."

The harder question is whether a charter school is a private participant or an arm of the state. If it is the state, the Establishment Clause forbids it to teach a faith. If it is private, the Free Exercise Clause forbids the state to exclude it for teaching one. WVLT reports that the judge found privately operated charter schools are not strictly government actors.

The rest of the case turns on that finding.

What the Order Does

The order tells the Knox County board that it may not deny Wilberforce's application because the school is religious. WVLT reports that it applies to Wilberforce and Knox County and no one else.

Wilberforce must still apply and meet every other requirement. The board may still say no for reasons unrelated to faith. WVLT reports that the school has already missed the application deadline for the 2027 to 2028 school year.

Carly Harrington, a spokesperson for Knox County Schools, said the district and the county law department are "reviewing the opinion." An appeal would go to the Sixth Circuit.

The Fair Objection

Not everyone who opposes this school opposes religion, and the opponents' strongest argument deserves a fair hearing.

A group of Tennessee parents and officials from non religious charter schools intervened in the case. Chalkbeat reports their concern: a religious charter would be "classified and treated as private schools," and no one has worked out what that means for the public funding formula or for the protections owed to students with disabilities. If a charter school is private enough to teach a faith, is it public enough to be bound by every rule that binds a public school? Nothing reported from the ruling answers that question.

Tennessee's own officials are divided. Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti published an opinion saying the state has "no compelling interest" in keeping religious schools out of a public benefit. He then declined to join the lawsuit, Chalkbeat reports.

The Part Supporters Must Accept

A door the Constitution opens for a Christian school stays open for schools of other faiths.

Josh Hedrick, a Knoxville attorney, told WVLT what he expects. "The way the court's interpreting this, you cannot exclude a religion." He added, "You could have really anything." The money, he said, would have to be shared on equal terms.

That follows from the ruling's own logic. A Christian who welcomes the decision is also accepting a Tennessee in which an Islamic academy may apply on the same form and draw from the same fund. The liberty Wilberforce claimed protects the schools its supporters would not choose, or it protects no one.

Zach Wishart, the director of Wilberforce, called the decision a victory for religious liberty and said he hopes it opens the way for other Christian operators. If the ruling stands, it opens the way for operators of other faiths as well.

Why One District Court Matters

The Supreme Court took up this question in 2025, in a case over a Catholic virtual charter school in Oklahoma. On May 22 of that year the justices split four to four, with Justice Barrett taking no part. A tie affirms the ruling below and sets no precedent for anyone else. We wrote about what followed in Oklahoma in September.

The question remains open. Hedrick told WVLT that a Sixth Circuit opinion in this case "would be cited to and referred to for a long time to come."

What You Can Do

Read past the first line of any story about this case, including ours. Ask the two questions the judge had to ask: who runs the school, and who is being turned away for what reason. Pray for the people on both sides of the Knox County table. They are neighbors, and they are arguing about children.

If this piece helped you think the case through, share it with someone who sees it differently.

Sources

  • Knoxville News Sentinel (Anthony Nicotera), "New Knox County ruling opens door to religious charter schools in Tennessee," updated November 9, 2026, as carried by Yahoo News: yahoo.com
  • WVLT, "Federal judge sides with proposed Knoxville Christian school seeking charter status from Knox County school board," November 10, 2026: wvlt.tv
  • WVLT, "Attorney says federal ruling on Christian charter school could extend to other religions," November 10, 2026: wvlt.tv
  • Chalkbeat Tennessee (Melissa Brown), "Federal lawsuit over Tennessee's religious charter school ban advances," June 11, 2026: chalkbeat.org
  • CourtListener docket, The Wilberforce Academy of Knoxville v. Knox County Board of Education, No. 3:25-cv-00584: courtlistener.com
  • SCOTUSblog case file, Oklahoma Statewide Charter School Board v. Drummond, No. 24-394, decided May 22, 2025: scotusblog.com