A Catholic Grotto in Kentucky and a Mosque in New Jersey Ask Their Towns One Question

I have never read my own town's zoning code. Then the Supreme Court took a Catholic grotto case from Kentucky, and a New Jersey mosque's five year wait landed in the same week. A reflection built on our own reporting.

A Catholic Grotto in Kentucky and a Mosque in New Jersey Ask Their Towns One Question

I have never read my own town's zoning code. I know where the church parks its cars and where the dumpster goes, and I have never once asked who decided.

Two stories from the past week made me ask. On October 1 the Supreme Court agreed to hear the case of a Catholic nonprofit that wants a shrine to the Virgin Mary beside its church in Park Hills, Kentucky. The Associated Press calls it a shrine. A local outlet, LINK nky, calls it a grotto: a small structure shaped like a cave, built to hold a statue.

The day before, our edition had covered a Muslim congregation in Marlboro Township, New Jersey, that spent nearly five years trying to get a mosque approved. A federal complaint now says the township held it to rules it did not apply to others.

A statue and a mosque. What could they possibly have in common?

They have a map in common, and a board that decides what goes on it. In Park Hills the zoning board approved a variance in 2021. A neighboring family challenged it, Kentucky's courts sided with the neighbors, and in December 2025 the Kentucky Supreme Court held that the board never had the authority to grant it. The neighbors also told the courts, according to the AP, that the church knew the ordinances barred a shrine when it bought the property. That is a fair argument, and our Advocate said so.

Both cases run through the same federal statute, the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act, enacted September 22, 2000. One of its rules bars a government from treating a religious assembly on less than equal terms with a nonreligious one. That is a sentence about a gym and a church, and about who gets the variance.

I keep thinking about the ordinary parts of this. Nobody in either town set out to rule on the kingdom of God. A board met, a neighbor objected, a clerk checked a code. Isaiah says the Lord's house shall be called a house of prayer for all peoples, and I notice how rarely we imagine that promise arriving as a hearing on a setback line.

The liberty I claim has to shield the person I disagree with. It is an easy sentence to say about someone else's building. It gets harder when the building is next door to me and the statue faces my window.

Here is what we do not know. We found no argument date in the Park Hills case. We do not know how broadly the justices will rule, and a grant is not a ruling on who is right. Where the sources disagreed, in our earlier reporting, we said so there. This piece adds no new fact.

I have still not read the code. This week I will find it, and I will look at how my town treats a church next to how it treats a club. Do the same, and tell me what you find.

Drawn from our own dispatches (no new factual claims)

  • Advocate, October 2, the Park Hills grotto: https://www.theredlighthouse.org/advocate-park-hills-grotto-supreme-court-rluipa/
  • Advocate, October 1, the Marlboro mosque: https://www.theredlighthouse.org/advocate-marlboro-mosque-denial-federal-complaint-rluipa/