Paul Wrote That When One Member Suffers, All Suffer. Most Mornings I Feel Nothing at All.

Paul wrote that when one member of the body suffers, all suffer together. Most mornings I read about a burned church and feel nothing. A reflection on 1 Corinthians 12 and the numb hand.

Paul Wrote That When One Member Suffers, All Suffer. Most Mornings I Feel Nothing at All.

Most mornings I read about a church that burned somewhere I will never go, and I feel nothing at all.

Not grief. Not anger. A small flicker of attention, the kind I give a weather alert for a county I do not live in, and then the coffee is ready and the flicker is gone. I have read the sentence "a church was set on fire" more times this year than I have read the Psalms, and I am not proud of the ratio.

Paul says something about this that I used to think was a description. I am starting to think it is a diagnosis.

What Paul actually wrote

"If one member suffers, all suffer together; if one member is honored, all rejoice together." That is 1 Corinthians 12:26. It comes at the end of his long argument about the body: the eye that cannot say to the hand, I have no need of you; the parts that seem weaker being indispensable.

Notice what he does not say. He does not say all should suffer together, as if it were an assignment. He says all do. It is written in the indicative. Paul is not handing the Corinthians a task. He is telling them what is already true about them, whether they feel it or not.

Which means that when I feel nothing, the body has not stopped being a body. Something in me has stopped reporting to it.

The numb hand

Anyone who has slept on an arm knows the feeling. You wake and the hand is there, attached, still yours, and you cannot feel it. You can look at it. You can see that it is cold. You know, as a fact, that it belongs to you. But the signal is not arriving.

The strange mercy of a numb hand is that feeling comes back the moment blood moves again. It comes back badly. Pins, needles, a kind of burning. Nobody enjoys it. But nobody who has felt it mistakes it for injury. It is the arm returning to the body.

I suspect much of what passes for compassion fatigue in the American church is simply this. We are not tired from feeling too much for the persecuted. We have been lying on the arm.

How blood moves

I do not have a technique for this, and I distrust anyone who sells one. But a few things have helped me, and none of them is dramatic.

Read slowly. One story, not ten. A headline is a weather alert. A name, a village, a time of night, read twice, is a person.

Say the place out loud in prayer, even when you are not sure you are pronouncing it right. God is not grading the vowels. The point is that your mouth has to make room for somewhere that is not here.

Let it cost you a minute you would have spent on something else. Paul's body language is not abstract. A body is fed and tired and late for work. If my members overseas are suffering and I am never once late for anything because of it, I should ask whether I am in the same body or only reading about it.

And when it hurts a little, when the feeling comes back as something closer to pins and needles than to warmth, do not take that as a sign you are doing it wrong. That is circulation.

Close

Tomorrow morning there will be another sentence about another church. I will probably feel the flicker and the coffee will probably be ready.

This time I want to sit with the cold hand a little longer. I want to read the name twice. I want to let the blood move, even if it stings.

If you want a place to start, our morning dispatch names one place and one people every day. Read it slowly. Say the name out loud. Then pass it to one person in your church who has also been lying on the arm.

Sources

  • 1 Corinthians 12:12 to 26 (ESV): esv.org