The Pentagon Will Livestream a December 3 Execution. Catholic and Evangelical Leaders Ask Who Has to Watch.

The Pentagon says the December 3 execution of Fort Hood gunman Nidal Hasan will be public and livestreamed. The head of the U.S. Catholic bishops asked for a rethink, and evangelical and Jewish leaders joined him. The argument is less about Hasan than about what watching does to us.

The Pentagon Will Livestream a December 3 Execution. Catholic and Evangelical Leaders Ask Who Has to Watch.

"We'll make sure that people are able to watch it, that it's public." The Defense Secretary said that on October 8, on a cable interview, about a man who is not dead yet. Pete Hegseth was describing the execution of Nidal Hasan, the former Army psychiatrist convicted of killing thirteen people at Fort Hood, Texas, in 2009.

The sentence is set for December 3, by firing squad, at Fort Hood. The acting Army secretary announced the date. Religion News Service reports that a Defense Department official confirmed the plan to livestream it, with details to come.

Be honest about the first thing you feel when you read that. For a lot of us it is not grief and it is not justice. It is a small flicker of interest, the kind that keeps a thumb moving. Nobody planned it. The phone was already in the hand.

That flicker is the subject. A military jury convicted Hasan, and almost no one in this argument disputes what he did. The head of the nation's Catholic bishops, Archbishop Paul Coakley, said Hasan's actions cannot be condoned. He still asked the Pentagon to reconsider, and he called a livestreamed execution a promotion of a culture of death.

Coakley's statement came Friday, October 9. He cited Romans 12:17, the line about not repaying evil for evil. He did not argue that Hasan is innocent. He argued about the audience.

He was not alone, and the objection did not stay in one pew. RNS reports that Walter Kim of the National Association of Evangelicals warned about a public spectacle, that Presiding Bishop Sean Rowe of the Episcopal Church called the idea reprehensible, and that Rabbi Jonah Pesner of the Union for Reform Judaism condemned it. Vice President JD Vance said he would not watch if it is livestreamed.

The other side deserves its own paragraph. RNS also reports that Pastor Doug Wilson says he prefers public executions, though he wants steps to prevent a circus, and that Pastor Robert Jeffress supports Hegseth's decision. Christians disagree about capital punishment itself, and this piece does not settle that. The narrower question is what happens to the people who are invited to watch.

Scripture has a line on that. In Deuteronomy 25, even a punishment the judge orders is capped, forty stripes and no more, and the reason given is about the onlooker: so that your brother is not degraded in your sight. The law does not say the guilty man is protected from the sentence. It says the watcher is protected from the contempt.

Gethsemane runs the other way. Jesus asks three friends to stay and keep watch with him through one night, and they sleep. It is the only watching the Gospels ask of us in the face of a death, and it is vigil, not viewing. Vigil is quiet. It has no feed and no comments. It does not make the dying a performance.

There are practical facts too. The president's approval, announced by the Pentagon on October 5, started a process, not a countdown. AP reports that Hasan could delay it, potentially for years, with a habeas appeal in civilian court, and OSV News reports that legal analysts say appeals could push the date past December 3. If carried out, it would be the first U.S. execution officials livestreamed, and the first by the military since 1961.

Sources disagree on small points and we note them. Catholic News Agency says the president approved the execution on October 2, while AP and Al Jazeera have the Pentagon announcing it on Monday, October 5. RNS names Kentucky in 1936 as the site of the last public execution in the United States, while OSV, citing the Death Penalty Information Center, says Missouri in 1937. Either way, it was the 1930s.

The date is December 3. Whether to watch will be decided in living rooms, one thumb at a time, and the people most likely to be asked are the ones who feel the flicker first.


Sources