Sign in Subscribe
The Discerner

The Law Arrives Quietly This Morning. The Sisters Are Already at the Bedsides.

The Law Arrives Quietly This Morning. The Sisters Are Already at the Bedsides.

Laws do not arrive the way we imagine. There is no bell, no procession. At midnight, somewhere in an Albany server, a date field ticked over, and New York became a state where a terminally ill person can ask a physician for the drugs to end their life. That is all. This morning the trains run, the coffee shops open, and the Medical Aid in Dying Act is simply in effect, the way gravity is in effect.

We told you on Monday about the four orders of Catholic sisters, the Carmelites, the Dominicans of Hawthorne, the Missionary Benedictines, the Little Sisters of the Poor, who sued rather than be pulled into the law’s machinery, and about the federal restraining order that shields them while the court decides. That shield holds this morning. New York agreed, on the record, not to apply the law to them for now. August 20 is the state’s deadline to answer. Nothing about that fight is finished.

But today I keep thinking about everyone the shield does not cover, and about a strange feature of days like this one: how the largest moral changes in a society arrive with the least noise.

When we debate a law, it is an argument, and arguments feel reversible. When a law takes effect, it becomes furniture. Within a year, it is simply how things are. Within five, questioning it sounds radical. The philosopher’s term for this is normalization, but Scripture has an older way of seeing it. The prophets rarely condemned Israel for a decision made loudly on one dramatic day. They condemned what the people had gotten used to. The idols were on the high places for generations; the trouble was not the day they went up but every quiet morning they were left standing. Habit, not argument, is how a society changes its mind about what a life is worth.

Which is why the most important thing happening in New York today is not in the statute books. It is at Rosary Hill Home in Hawthorne, where the Dominican sisters have tended the dying poor without charge for more than a century, and where this morning, as on every morning, someone is being fed, washed, and sat with, the way the order has done since before the state thought to regulate the question. The sisters’ argument to the court is legal. Their argument to the culture is simpler: they keep showing up. Every bed made, every hand held, every hour sat with the dying is a sentence in a counter argument that no legislature can repeal: you do not have to be useful to be loved, and you do not stop being ours because you are dying.

The supporters of this law are not villains, and it costs us nothing to say so. Many of them watched someone they love suffer, and they reached for the only mercy they could see. The Christian claim is not that their grief is fake. It is that there is a mercy older and stranger than the one on offer: “I was sick and you looked after me.” Present tense. A visited sickness, not a shortened one. The sisters have staked their lives on the idea that presence is the mercy, and starting this morning, New York will run the experiment in public: two answers to death, operating side by side, in the same state, under the same law.

Watch which one people choose when it is their mother. Watch August 20. And watch the sisters, who will not be watching any of it, because they will be at the bedsides, where they were yesterday, where they will be tomorrow.

The law arrived quietly this morning. So did they. They always have.

This piece is free. Send it to someone in New York, or to anyone who thinks the assisted suicide debate ended at midnight. It did not; it moved to the bedside. If you want the whole story, the courtroom, the deadline, the fight over conscience, join The Red Lighthouse as a member and read Monday’s lead. We will be watching August 20 so you do not have to.

Sources

Read next

Comments ()