Pakistan's Supreme Court Freed One Christian Brother and Upheld the Other's Death Sentence in One Ruling.

The Supreme Court of Pakistan acquitted Amoon Ayub and dismissed the appeal of his brother Qaiser on October 7. The reasoning turns on a phone line, an office lease and which devices held which files. A revision petition is planned.

Pakistan's Supreme Court Freed One Christian Brother and Upheld the Other's Death Sentence in One Ruling.

On Wednesday, October 7, the Supreme Court of Pakistan did two opposite things to two brothers in a single ruling.

It freed Amoon Ayub. It dismissed the appeal of his brother, Qaiser Ayub, which leaves in place a death sentence under Section 295-C, Pakistan's blasphemy law. Both men are Christians. A trial judge sentenced them together in December 2018. Both had spent years in custody waiting for this day.

The justices did not split the brothers by faith or by family. They split them by evidence, and the evidence is small: whose name was on a phone line, and which devices held which files.

What the court found on one brother's devices, and could not find on the other's, is the difference between going home and a sentence that still stands.